Elder Law Library for the Public
Tax Matters in Elder Law
Important Note: Tax is an extremely complex area of law. The information
provided here of necessity cannot describe every detail and exception.
The Disclaimer that applies
to this entire web site applies with particular emphasis here.
The discussion below on gift, estate, and generation-skipping transfer
taxes is broad in scope, because those taxes as a whole affect estate
planning and elder law. The income-tax itself, however, is much
broader in scope, and only certain issues frequently arise in elder
law, some of which are discussed below.
Gift and Estate Taxes
Q: What is the difference between the gift tax and the estate
tax?
Both are taxes on transfers that you make where you don't receive
something back of equivalent value. If you give something away during
life, that is a gift. If you die and leave something to someone,
that is a bequest. The gift is subject to the gift tax. The bequest
is subject to the estate tax.
The current estate tax was enacted in 1916 and is the fourth estate
tax in U.S. history. Its primary purpose was to prevent the accumulation
of too much power in a few private hands. The gift tax was enacted
in 1932 to prevent easy deathbed circumvention of the estate tax.
Q: How do gift and estate taxes work?
The gift and estate tax is in essence one single tax. You can give
away the following without paying any gift or estate tax:
- Gifts (remember, a gift is during your life only) of $11,000
per year per recipient ($110,000 to your non-U.S. Citizen spouse);
plus
- Gifts of any amount for anyone's tuition (not room, board, books,
or other expenses) so long as the payment is directly to the educational
institution; plus
- Gifts of any amount for anyone's medical expenses, so long as
the payment is made directly to the medical provider; plus
- Gifts and bequests of an unlimited amount to your U.S. Citizen
spouse; plus
- In addition to all of the above, total lifetime gifts and bequests
of $1,000,000.
Beyond this amount, you will have to pay gift or estate taxes of
between 41% and 50% of the excess.
Q: I've got everything set up so that it avoids probate. Doesn't
that avoid the estate tax?
No. Your probate estate is only a part of your taxable estate.
Assets in your taxable estate are valued at their fair market value
as of the date of your death, not what you paid for the assets,
not "fire sale" prices, and not the town's property tax
assessed value. Your taxable estate includes, among other things:
- All assets you own in your own name.
- All assets titled to your revocable living trust, if you have
one.
- All assets (not just half of each asset) held jointly with anyone
other than your U.S. citizen spouse, if the asset was yours to
begin with, or if you provided the money to purchase it.
- The full value of all assets in which you have retained a life
estate.
- The full value of all "pay on death" or "in trust
for" accounts.
- The full value of assets with beneficiary designations (like
annuities and life insurance).
- The full, untaxed value of your IRAs and Qualified Retirement
Plans.
- The death proceeds (not merely the current cash surrender value)
of all life insurance policies on your life, including group term,
if you have any control over the policy. (While life insurance
proceeds are usually free of income taxes, they are usually not
free of estate taxes.)
Have the discipline to list all of your assets and add up their
values. It is human nature to dramatically underestimate the sum
of a list of numbers.
Q: How about if I just sell my house to my son for $1?
This is a taxable gift, regardless of its form being a "sale."
The consequences of trying to outsmart the system like this are
rarely pleasant, and can include the following:
- Your son has the legal right to evict you.
- If your son dies, his spouse may inherit your home and have
the legal right to evict you.
- You are no longer eligible for the $250,000 capital gains tax
exemption ($500,000 for a married couple) when you sell your home.
- If you continue to live in your home until you die, the home
is included in your taxable estate anyway.
- If you do not live in your home until you die, or if your son
sells your home before you die, your son will have a capital gains
tax (computed using your cost basis).
- You have made a disqualifying transfer for Medicaid purposes.
Q: Does Massachusetts have its own gift and estate tax?
Massachusetts has no gift tax.
Massachusetts used to be a "sponge-tax" or "pickup-tax"
state for estate taxes. That means that Massachusetts only took
an amount that the federal government would share dollar for dollar
with states from the federal estate tax. Thus, the sponge-tax did
not increase your estate tax; it just diverted some of it from the
federal government to the state.
However, the federal 2001 tax act changed the federal law to drastically
reduce the amount of federal estate tax that the federal government
would share with the states. Like many states have done in response
to this, Massachusetts just changed its estate tax law effective
for persons dying after 2002. Unfortunately, the law was drafted
in such a way that there is no consensus at this writing as to what
it means. The Mass Chapter of NAELA expects that the law will be
clarified, by regulation or statute, before 2003. Depending on the
result, married couples with estates in excess of $675,000 may need
to revise their estate plans.
Q: I heard that the estate tax was repealed. Are you saying
it's not?
That is correct. Under the tax act of 2001, the federal estate
tax exemption is scheduled to increase, and the top tax rate to
decrease, as shown in the table below. Full repeal does not occur
until the year 2010, and the repeal lasts for only one year. After
that, in 2011, the full estate tax comes roaring back, with only
a $1,000,000 exemption, and a 55% top rate that is higher than we
have today.
|
Estate Tax
|
|
Year
|
Exemption
|
Top Rate
|
|
2002
|
$1,000,000
|
50%
|
|
2003
|
$1,000,000
|
49%
|
|
2004
|
$1,500,000
|
48%
|
|
2005
|
$1,500,000
|
47%
|
|
2006
|
$2,000,000
|
46%
|
|
2007
|
$2,000,000
|
45%
|
|
2008
|
$2,000,000
|
45%
|
|
2009
|
$3,500,000
|
45%
|
|
2010
|
Estate Tax Repealed
|
|
|
2011
|
$1,000,000
|
55%
|
Q: Why is the repeal for only one year, and why in 2010?
The repeal is phased in from now until 2010 in order to delay projected
budget deficits, and therefore make repeal more politically palatable.
The repeal is temporary because of a Senate rule. Because repeal
will reduce government revenues, Senate rules require that a permanent
repeal obtain 60 votes to pass. Advocates for permanent repeal were
unable to obtain the 60 votes, but were able to muster a majority.
In order for a majority less than 60 to pass the bill, the repeal
had to "sunset" after 10 years.
Q: What about the gift tax? Is it repealed?
No. The gift tax exemption stays level at $1,000,000, even as the
estate tax exemption rises to $3,500,000, and even during 2010 when
the estate tax is repealed. The rationale seems to be twofold. First,
to prevent large-scale shifting of income-producing assets, or of
built-in capital gains, to lower-bracket taxpayers. Second, in case
the estate tax comes back with a $1,000,000 exemption in 2011, to
prevent widespread circumvention of that "reborn" estate
tax by gifting during the years 2004 to 2010.
Q: I don't have a taxable estate and never will. Why should
I care about the estate tax?
Two reasons. First, your heirs may have taxable estates themselves.
If so, their inheritance from you might best be left to them in
a way so as not to add to their taxable estates.
Second, and more important, how you own your assets, and whether
or not they are includible in your taxable estate, can have dramatic
income-tax consequences, even if you do not have a taxable estate.
See the section on Income Taxes below.
Generation-Skipping Transfer Tax
Q: What is the Generation-Skipping Transfer Tax?
Congress wants to collect an estate tax at the death of each generation.
If instead of leaving assets to your children, you give assets (by
gift or bequest) to your grandchildren or a younger generation,
the federal government would "miss out" on the estate
tax when your children die. So instead, when you make gifts or bequests
to grandchildren or younger generations, the federal government
takes a Generation-Skipping Transfer Tax ("GSTT") of 50%.
This is after the gift or estate tax.
The GSTT also applies if you make gifts or bequests to non-family
members who are more than 37-_ years younger than you are.
Like the gift and estate tax, there is an exemption for the GSTT.
The exemption amount is $1,100,000. Beginning in 2004, the GSTT
exemption will always equal the estate tax exemption, shown in the
table above.
To illustrate, if you are in the highest estate tax bracket of
50%, have used all of your GSTT exemption, and want to leave a bequest
to a grandchild of $100, it will cost you $400 to do that. Of the
$400, 50% ($200) is taken in estate taxes, then another 50% of the
remaining $200 ($100) is taken in GSTT.
|